The Best Baby Mattress in 2024

Finding the right baby mattress is crucial for your little one's safety and comfort during sleep. A crib mattress must fit snugly within the crib, meeting specific size regulations to prevent risks. This article guides you through the key features and top-rated mattresses that promote restful sleep for your baby night after night. Trust us; this is a cozy read you won't want to miss!

Key Features to Consider When Choosing a Baby Mattress

When choosing a baby mattress, it’s important to consider safety and certifications, comfort and support, durability, and easy maintenance. These key features will ensure your little one gets the best sleep possible.

Safety and Certifications

Safety should always be at the forefront when selecting your baby’s mattress. Look for products certified by reputable organizations, such as the Consumer Product Safety Commission (CPSC).

These certifications mean that the mattress meets strict safety standards and doesn’t exceed 6 inches thick to prevent hazards like entrapment or suffocation. Ensure it fits snugly in a crib with dimensions of at least 27¼ inches wide and 51¼ inches long, as defined by the CSPC.

A good baby mattress will also come with additional endorsements from groups like GREENGUARD or CertiPUR-US, which test for harmful chemical emissions and ensure that only safe materials are used.

This peace of mind is critical because your little one will spend many hours on this surface. With these checks off your list, you can focus next on finding a mattress that combines both comfort and support.

Comfort and Support

A baby mattress must offer just the right amount of firmness for your little one’s safety and developing bodies. Too soft, and it could pose a risk; too firm, and your baby might not sleep well.

The best mattresses balance comfort with solid support, keeping your baby’s spine properly aligned as they grow. Look for options that maintain this critical balance, like the Moonlight Slumber Little Dreamer or Delta Eco Classica III, both designed to nurture healthy bone development.

Ensure the baby mattress you choose doesn’t sag under your baby’s weight. This ensures consistent support throughout their rest. Check out features such as additional layers for coziness like those found in Naturepedic or Newton crib mattresses without compromising on the all-important supportive base layer.

It’s essential that while pampering their tender skin with soft materials, babies still receive stern enough support to thrive physically as they doze off into dreamland on their comfy yet robust sanctuary.

Durability and Easy Maintenance

After ensuring your little one’s comfort and support, you’ll want to focus on the longevity of their sleeping space. A durable baby mattress withstands the test of time, resisting wear and tear from nightly use and the inevitable accidents that come with parenting.

Mattresses crafted with high-quality materials don’t just offer extended lifespans; they also make cleanup a breeze. Features like water-resistant covers or baby mattress protectors can save time and effort during those middle-of-the-night changes.

Maintenance should be simple so that you can focus more on precious moments rather than chores. Look for options where the baby mattress cover is machine-washable, cutting down on laundry stress.

And if you’re constantly on the go, selecting a lightweight design helps in easy crib sheet changes without breaking a sweat. By choosing a mattress that prioritizes both durability and ease of maintenance, rest assured, knowing you’re investing in hassle-free nights ahead for both you and your child.

Top Picks for the Best Baby Mattresses

Newton Baby Crib Mattress and Toddler Bed

Top-notch design

The best baby mattress for safety, comfort, and easy maintenance.
Best Overall

Find on Amazon


  • Hypoallergenic and breathable Wovenaire fill material

  • Water-resistant and washable cover for easy maintenance

  • Encased coil type for added support and comfort

  • Designed to fit standard crib dimensions (52\”L x 28\”W x 5.5\”Th)

  • Suitable for both crib mattress and toddler bed use

  • Easy-care machine washable product care instructions

The Newton Baby Crib Mattress and Toddler Bed stands out for its commitment to your child’s safety and comfort. Recognizing the worry of ensuring a safe sleeping environment, this mattress offers peace of mind with its 100% breathable design, proven to reduce suffocation risk. As children grow from infants to toddlers, their needs change — but not all mattresses address these evolving requirements. This one does: it’s a 2-stage mattress that provides necessary support while keeping in line with your baby’s developmental stages.

Parents applaud the practicality of having a washable mattress—everything from the cover to the core can be cleaned, setting a new standard in nursery hygiene. The materials used are non-toxic, free of foam, glue, latex, or springs—substances you wouldn’t want near your newborn or toddler for extended periods. Plus, there’s no compromise on comfort; many moms have noted how well-rested their babies seem after sleeping on this deluxe 5.5″ thick bed.

Choosing Newton Baby Crib Mattress as our top pick wasn’t just about ticking boxes; it was witnessing countless nights of uninterrupted sleep for both babies and parents. Its innovative design fits within most standard cribs effortlessly and underscores what modern parenting is all about: convenience without ever sacrificing quality or well-being. It truly sets itself apart as an essential investment for any family looking to give their little one the safest start in life wrapped up in cozy comfort each night.


  • Washable cover and core for easy cleaning

  • 100% breathable mattress to reduce suffocation risk

  • 2-stage design supports baby through all stages of development

  • Made without foam, glue, latex, or springs


  • Limited color options

  • Higher price point compared to traditional mattresses

  • May not fit non-standard crib sizes

The Newton Baby Crib Mattress and Toddler Bed is perfect for parents prioritizing their baby’s safety, comfort, and overall well-being. With its 100% breathable design and washable materials, this mattress is ideal for a safe and easy-to-maintain option. Give your little one the gift of better sleep with the Newton Baby Crib Mattress and Toddler Bed – get yours today.

Dourxi Crib Mattress

Wool and foam construction

Breathable dual-sided design for baby’s comfortable snooze-time.
Runner Up

Find on Amazon


  • Dourxi Crib Mattress is made of wool and foam for a comfortable sleep experience.

  • The Memory Foam comfort layer provides additional support and cushioning

  • Enjoy the benefits of a 60-day no-questions-asked return policy and limited 10-year warranty

  • This mattress comes with a removable cover in blue and white color options

  • The lightweight and breathable design makes it easy to care for and maintain

  • With dimensions of 52″L x 27.5″W x 6″Th, this mattress is designed to fit most standard-sized cribs

The Dourxi Crib Mattress stands out as a top contender for your little one’s sweet dreams, snagging the No. 3 spot on our list with good reason. Its innovative dual-sided design offers just the proper support for infants and toddlers alike—a firmer side ensures safe sleep for babies. In comparison, a cushier memory foam side cradles your toddler in comfort. This feature alone makes the Dourxi an investment that grows with your child, from those first nights at home to the fearless leaps of a bustling toddler.

One mom shared how her fussy sleeper was transformed into a full-night dreamer when they switched to this mattress; its gel-infused memory foam comforted her child and kept them cool throughout summer nights. The easiness of slipping off the cover and washing away any accidents is another massive win for busy parents who value practicality and hygiene. And let’s not overlook safety—the CertiPUR-US certified foam means you’re providing a sleeping environment free from harmful chemicals.

Finally, by selecting this mattress, you won’t be second-guessing if it will suit your crib – its standard size fits perfectly in all standard cribs and toddler beds, making installation secure and hassle-free. With customer support just an email away, peace of mind comes easy, knowing that quality assurance and guidance are within reach whenever needed.


  • Non-toxic, CertiPUR-US certified foam ensures safety for infants and toddlers

  • Removable and washable outer cover provides convenience and cleanliness

  • Triple-layered design with gel-infused memory foam offers temperature regulation for a comfortable sleep environment

  • Dual-sided firmness caters to both infants and toddlers for proper support and maximum comfort


  • Mattress may emit an initial odor upon unboxing due to compression and requires 72 hours for proper expansion

  • Non-waterproof cover needs extra care when cleaning and might require frequent washings

  • May not fit non-standard or custom-sized cribs

This Dourxi Crib Mattress is perfect for new parents who value the safety, comfort, and quality of their baby’s sleep. With its dual-sided design, breathable materials, and easy-to-clean cover, this mattress is a great snooze spot. Invest in the best for your baby’s sleep – try the Dourxi Crib Mattress.

Graco Premium Crib & Toddler Mattress


Super-thick foam for your baby to sink into.
Most Convenient

Find on Amazon


  • Made with high-density foam for recommended firmness

  • Machine-washable cover for easy cleaning

  • Greenguard-certified for safe indoor air quality

  • Waterproof feature to protect the mattress

  • Removable cover made of polyester material

  • Fits standard cribs and toddler beds

The Graco Premium Crib & Toddler Mattress sets a new standard for baby’s sleep safety and comfort. As moms, we constantly worry about the air our little ones breathe, especially indoors. This mattress eases those concerns with its GREENGUARD Gold Certification, ensuring it has passed rigorous tests for harmful chemicals and pollutants. Imagine your child sleeping peacefully on a surface that is not only comfy but also promotes healthier indoor air quality.

In today’s busy world, convenience is key, which is why the machine-washable cover of this mattress is such a game-changer. Spills and accidents are no match for its 100% waterproof sleep surface; simply unzip the cover and toss it in the wash. After nap time or a night of uninterrupted sleep—because this supportive CertiPUR-US certified foam helps with that, too—you can keep your baby’s sleeping environment fresh and clean without hassle.

Durability meets practicality as this Graco mattress fits seamlessly into any standard full-size crib or toddler bed. It makes transitioning from infant to toddler stages smooth sailing while offering lasting firmness needed to support growing bones. The peace of mind knowing you’ve chosen one of the safest options for your precious bundle doesn’t hurt either!


  • GREENGUARD Gold certification ensures the mattress meets strict emissions standards, promoting healthier indoor air quality

  • CertiPUR-US-certified foam provides peace of mind that the mattress is made without harmful chemicals or metals like lead and mercury

  • Machine-washable cover with a 100% waterproof sleep surface makes cleaning and maintaining the mattress easy and hassle-free.

  • Fits standard full-size cribs and toddler beds, offering versatility for growing children


  • The mattress may have a slight odor when first unpacked

  • It requires up to 48 hours to fully expand after delivery

  • The cover needs to be air-dried and cannot be placed in a dryer

The Graco Premium Crib & Toddler Mattress is perfect for eco-conscious parents looking for a safe and comfortable sleep surface for their little one. With its comfy foam and machine washable cover, this mattress is ideal. Upgrade your baby’s sleeping experience today and give them the best with the Graco Premium Crib & Toddler Mattress.

Dream On Me Twilight Crib Mattress


Safe, supportive, and easy-to-clean crib mattress for your baby.
Best Waterproof

Find on Amazon


  • Triple laminated waterproof cover for easy cleaning and maintenance

  • Memory foam fill material for added comfort and support

  • Continuous coil design for durability and long-lasting use

  • Beige Cloud Vinyl Cover in a neutral color

  • 5-inch size provides a comfortable sleeping surface for your baby

  • Made in the USA, ensuring quality craftsmanship

The Dream On Me Twilight Crib Mattress brings peace of mind to moms with its Greenguard Gold Certification, ensuring it meets strict chemical emissions standards for a safer sleep environment. Constructed in the USA, this mattress is designed with 88 interwoven coils and a reinforced waterproof cover that keeps spills at bay and stands up against wear over time. The dual-sided design offers tailored comfort as your child grows from infant to toddler, making it a smart investment.

Ease of cleaning is another win for busy parents; the Twilight’s vinyl cover wipes down quickly without fuss—because, let’s face it, messes happen. And when it comes to durability, the included 10-year limited warranty speaks volumes about this mattress’s longevity. It fits snugly in standard cribs and beds, so you can rest assured that there are no unsafe gaps. Plus, flipping and rotating the mattress every few months allows even wear and extends its life span—a little action that goes a long way toward preserving your baby’s sleeping space.

Every detail of the Dream On Me Twilight has been considered with care—from easy maintenance to comfort assurance—to support babies as they drift off into dreamland night after night. This quality mattress adapts with your child through their precious first years of sleep while giving you one less thing to worry about on your parenting journey.


  • Fits all standard-size cribs and toddler beds for long-term use

  • Greenguard Gold Certified for safety and peace of mind

  • Dual-sided cushion provides comfort for infants and toddlers

  • 10-year manufacturer’s warranty for added assurance


  • Waterproof vinyl cover may produce crinkling noise

  • Mattress may have a slight odor upon unboxing

  • Expansion time for the mattress can vary based on surrounding temperature

The Dream On Me Twilight Crib Mattress is perfect for new parents looking for a safe and supportive mattress for their little one. With its Greenguard Gold certification and waterproof cover, this mattress offers easy maintenance. Invest in the best for your baby’s sleep – get the Dream On Me Twilight now.

Dream On Me Honeycomb Orthopedic Crib Mattress

Worth the splurge

Superior orthopedic support to keep your little one comfy and cozy.
Best Premium

Find on Amazon


  • Waterproof vinyl cover for easy cleaning and maintenance

  • Gel memory foam provides orthopedic support for baby’s comfort

  • Hand wash-only care instructions for convenient maintenance

  • Standard size fits most baby cribs

  • Firm fiber construction promotes healthy spinal alignment

  • White color complements any nursery decor

As parents, we want the absolute best for our little ones, especially when it comes to their comfort and safety while sleeping. The Dream On Me Honeycomb Orthopedic Firm Fiber Crib Mattress is a solid choice for your nursery. Its 5” fiber core delivers support crucial for infants and toddlers as they grow. Unlike some mattresses that tend to sag over time, this one is built to maintain its shape and provide a stable sleeping surface.

Your baby’s health is also at the forefront with this mattress. It’s Greenguard Gold Certified, ensuring it meets strict air quality standards. Plus, being free from harmful chemicals such as phthalates and lead makes it a smart pick for cautious moms who are vigilant about what their children come into contact with day-to-day. The waterproof vinyl cover adds a stylish touch and stands up against spills and accidents – just wipe down with mild soap and warm water without any hassle.

Made in the USA, durability comes hand-in-hand with the peace of mind offered by the 10-year warranty backing this crib mattress. With dimensions perfectly fitting standard cribs and toddler beds, transitioning from one sleep stage to another becomes seamless for your child – making bedtime less of a chore and more of restful haven each night.


  • Provides firm support for growing children with a 5” fiber core

  • Easy maintenance with a waterproof, vented cover to keep the mattress hygienic and fresh

  • Stylish white honeycomb vinyl cover that is easy to clean

  • Guarantees safety as it’s Greenguard Gold and JPMA Certified, meeting all flammability, phthalate, and lead tests


  • The mattress may feel too firm for some infants and toddlers

  • The vinyl cover may not be as breathable as other materials, potentially leading to heat retention

  • At 8 lbs, the mattress can be relatively heavy for frequent lifting or changing sheets

If you’re a parent looking for a supportive, durable, and easy-to-maintain mattress for your baby’s crib, this one is ideal. Don’t settle for anything less than the best. Click “add to cart” now and give your little one the sleep they deserve.

Serta Perfect Start Baby Mattress

Kind to the Earth

An eco-friendly choice for your family.
Best Eco-Friendly

Find on Amazon


  • Waterproof and stain-resistant feature

  • Made with durable and lightweight materials

  • Double-sided for extended use

  • Greenguard Gold-certified for improved indoor air quality

  • Memory foam comfort layer for optimal support

  • Generous size of 52″ x 27.5″ x 6″

The Serta Perfect Start Baby Mattress offers a sanctuary of comfort and safety for your child’s sleep needs. Crafted with expertise in infant and toddler bedding, this dual-sided mattress is more than just a sleeping surface; it’s an investment in your baby’s health and well-being. Its premium, sustainably sourced fiber core provides the firm support recommended for newborns while also adapting to the growing needs of toddlers. The waterproof and easy-to-clean cover ensures that accidental spills won’t be a lasting problem, making maintenance a breeze.

Safety doesn’t take a backseat with this USA-made mattress as it boasts GREENGUARD Gold Certification—your assurance that you’re not exposing your little one to harmful chemicals while they sleep. Plus, knowing that it surpasses stringent flammability standards gives you peace of mind during those precious moments when you watch your baby slumber. In addition to its health benefits, practical features such as lightweight design make changing sheets effortless, and squared corners ensure the perfect fit inside cribs or toddler beds.

Installing the Serta Perfect Start Crib Mattress into your nursery is straightforward – no complex setup here. Remember to give it time after unboxing; as many parents have noted, allowing 24-72 hours lets the mattress fully expand for optimal use. With its thoughtful design promoting cleaner indoor air quality and its resilient construction backed by a seven-year warranty, this mattress stands out as essential for any mindful parent’s nursery checklist.


  • Dual-sided design for infants and toddlers

  • Waterproof cover for easy cleaning

  • GREENGUARD Gold certified for low chemical emissions

  • Lightweight and square corner design


  • Mattress may have a slight odor upon opening due to packaging, but it dissipates quickly

  • Some customers found the mattress to be too firm for their liking

  • The waterproof vinyl cover can produce some noise with movement

Are you a new parent looking for the perfect mattress to provide your baby with a safe, comfortable, and healthy sleep environment? Look no further than Serta Perfect Start Baby Mattress – the ideal choice for eco-conscious families. Upgrade your nursery today and give your little one a premium sleeping experience lasting from infancy to toddlerhood.


Q: What is a baby mattress?

A: A baby mattress is a specially designed mattress for use in cribs or toddler beds to provide a comfortable and supportive sleep surface for infants and young children.

Q: What is the difference between a baby mattress and a crib mattress?

A: Baby mattress and crib mattress are often used interchangeably to refer to the same product, a mattress designed for use in a crib or toddler bed to ensure a safe and comfortable sleep environment for babies.

Q: Are baby mattresses waterproof?

A: Many baby mattresses are waterproof to protect against spills and accidents, ensuring easy cleanup and maintaining a hygienic sleep surface for the baby.

Q: What is a 100-night free trial for a baby mattress?

A: A 100-night free trial typically allows customers to try out a baby mattress for 100 nights and return it for a full refund if they are not satisfied with the product, offering peace of mind and confidence in the purchase.

Q: Can a baby crib mattress be used as a toddler mattress?

A: Yes, many baby crib mattresses are designed to be used as both a crib mattress and a toddler mattress, offering versatility and extended use as the child grows.

Q: Are foam mattresses suitable for baby cribs?

A: Foam mattresses designed specifically for baby cribs meet safety and comfort standards, providing a supportive sleep surface for infants and young children.

Q: What are the features of the best sellers in baby mattresses?

A: The best-selling baby mattresses often offer features such as dual-sided design for extended use, breathability, waterproof protection, and washable covers, providing convenience and functionality for parents.

Q: Is there such thing as an organic baby crib mattress?

A: Yes, organic crib mattresses are available, made from natural and sustainable materials without harmful chemicals, offering a healthy and eco-friendly sleep environment for infants.

Q: Are there specific mattresses for mini cribs?

A: Yes, mini crib mattresses are designed to fit the smaller dimensions of mini cribs, providing a snug and secure sleep surface for little ones in compact cribs.

Q: Can I find a washable crib mattress for easy maintenance?

A: Yes, washable crib mattresses are available with machine-washable covers, providing convenient and hygienic cleaning options for parents and caregivers.


When it comes to giving your baby a serene sleep environment, nothing tops the Newton Baby Crib Mattress and Toddler Bed with its breathable and hypoallergenic qualities. The added convenience of a water-resistant and washable cover makes life easier. However, take into account your unique preference before hitting the checkout; our guide talks you through the lot.

About the Author

Tanja is a proud mom to her twins Hailey and Bethany. She has blossomed into motherhood since giving birth, and she spends her time doting on the twins and giving them the best upbringing she possibly can.

She's forever experimenting with new parenting gadgets and baby formulas, and scours parenting blogs to gain insight from other moms.

Why Trust Us

Since 2010, Momtastic has provided millions of parents with a complete guide to raising a family in a healthy home by offering our expert advice on everything from car seats for kids to baking supplies for the kitchen. It takes a village to raise a family, and our experts are here to make sure every parent finds a little bit of that village in us.